Does Elizabeth Warren Have a Piece of Racist Memorabilia on Her Kitchen Shelf?

Accusations of racism were based solely on a blurry and obscured glimpse of an object on Sen. Elizabeth Warren's shelf.

Image via Wikimedia Commons

Claim

A photograph shows a piece of racist memorabilia on Elizabeth Warren's kitchen shelf.

Rating

Origin

In January 2019, a number of online trolls spread a graphic accusing Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) of keeping an object of racist memorabilia — a caricature figurine depicting a black child eating a slice of watermelon — atop her kitchen cabinets.

This spurious claim was initially pushed by users on the Internet forum 4Chan and the r/The_Donald section of Reddit, but it was also promoted to a larger audience by Fox News contributor Tomi Lahren (who later deleted her tweet on the subject):

This accusation was based solely on an obscured glimpse of an object that was only partly visible in the background of an Instagram Live Q&A video. While some Internet users apparently saw what they wanted to see when they glimpsed this object, a closer inspection revealed that the knickknack on Warren’s shelf was not in fact a piece of antiquated racist memorabilia.

Here’s a better look at what’s actually on Senator Warren’s shelf. The supposed “racist figurine” appears to be nothing more than an ordinary reproduction of a Greek urn or vase:

Kristen Orthman, Warren’s press secretary, provided us with a few photographs showing the items atop the senator’s kitchen cabinets. The first image is a screenshot of Warren’s Instagram Live video, the second is a photograph taken from a similar angle as the Instagram Live video, and the final photograph provides an unimpeded look at the object on Warren’s shelf:

Senator Elizabeth Warren does not have a racist piece of memorabilia atop her kitchen cabinets. This accusation was made in bad faith and without evidence in an attempt to smear the Massachusetts politician.

Sources
  • CBS News.   “Elizabeth Warren Talks Iowa Trip, Drinking Beer on Instagram Live.”
        2 January 2019.

Dear Reader,

stangertoyota.com has long been engaged in the battle against misinformation, an effort we could not sustain without support from our audience. Producing reliable fact-checking and thorough investigative reporting requires significant resources. We pay writers, editors, web developers, and other staff who work tirelessly to provide you with an invaluable service: evidence-based, contextualized analysis of facts. Help us keep stangertoyota.com strong. Make a direct contribution today. Learn More.

Donate with PayPal